"The views expressed by others are not necessarily shared by me personally but all views and perspectives are respected"
Letter from the family of Paul Vigay, August 25th 2012

The alleged claims and photographs presented by Robbert van den Broeke have just been brought
to our attention. As the family of Paul Vigay we feel that it would have been common courtesy for us
to have been informed directly, before it being published around the internet and becoming part of a
public controversy. We feel that no sensitivity or respect has been shown to the families of the four
men who are currently the subjects of these claims and this is upsetting.

We would like to echo the objections which we have read in the statement from Pat Delgado's family.
We believe these alleged reports to be false and find it hard to believe that anyone would take them
at all seriously.

We do not recognise Paul in the message Robbert van den Broeke claims to have come from him
and do not believe that it would be Paul's wish for his name and his image to be used in this way.  
This appears to be a disingenuous attempt at political point scoring, abusing the truth and
reputations of our loved ones to try and add value and status to the personal work of Robbert van
den Broeke and Nancy Talbott. If their work has truth and value it does not need the defence of the
dead who it is (in) conveniently not possible to question on this matter.

I  (Paul's sister) believe in a spirit life as did my brother and would fully welcome any genuine
communication or evidence from my brother, either directly or through a medium. In my opinion
these reports do not provide any such evidence and can only be damaging to the work of authentic

In his life, Paul worked with many different people of many different and sometimes opposing
viewpoints, whilst maintaining and evaluating his own independent thoughts and opinions in his
research/search for truth about crop circles and other issues. We cannot know where his research
would have developed and what his views would be in current debates. It is insulting to his integrity
for him to be used to add weight to some kind of personal attack against his former friend and
colleague, Colin Andrews.

                   Frances Vigay (sister) and on behalf of my parents.
Paul Vigay
Medium Robbert van den
Broeke claims images of
Pat Delgado and David
Chorley appeared on his
camera with messages
for Robbert and Nancy
Talbott. The Delgado
Family Issue statement
Medium Robbert van den
Broeke claims two more
deceased Crop Circle
Researchers, Paul Vigay
and David Kingston
appeared with messages
and warnings for Colin
The Family of David
Chorley issue a statement
and warning to Robbert
van den Broeke. No
response from Robbert or
Nancy Talbott.

The Family of Paul Vigay Issue Statement - to be sent to
Medium Robbert van den Broeke
Posted August 26, 2012
Colin Andrews Comment:

Following the statements made by these families and myself, no response has been forthcoming from Nancy Talbott
or Robbert van den Broeke. Most people who have followed the crop circle subject will be aware of the shock that was
endured by the sudden death of this young, likeable and loving man, Paul Vigay.  Paul was also one of the few who
did excellent research in the field. A full understanding is demanded of what has transpired with these claims by
Robbert and posted on Nancy Talbott's website. If they believe these photographic images are real and the
messages too, then common respect and dignity for the families  and myself, to whom messages and a warning were
allegedly sent, should be forthcoming. An in depth investigation into part of these claims is near completion and will
be posted soon.

Only when all sides and all beliefs find common ground to share details and data, will such seemingly outrageous
claims be understood and moved forward. As things stand, this is a very sad day when the names of loved ones are
used by someone, or something (unproven) with such total disregard for the feelings of those affected.

Let me spell this out one more time for those who keep going deaf regarding my extensive efforts to contact Robbert,
Stan and also Gatekeeper Nancy Talbott..  I have tried numerous times directly and via mutual friends of Nancy
Talbott to discuss these cases, to talk to Robbert and or Stan themselves.  Each approach has been met with, not just
refusal but negative and aggressive words from Talbott. A challenge for Robbert to work on a sitting with me was
suggested by David Haith on this website and that challenge was conveyed to a person called Enrico who works on
Robberts website, to be forwarded to him.  Many messages and peaceful approaches were  communicated to Enrico
as well as others who prefer I do not name.

The Chorley family have also made efforts to reach Nancy Talbott directly and so far again she has not responded.
None of the families or myself have received any communications from these people.

Enrico from the Netherlands who helps Robbert van den Broeke with his website has responded to the latest posting
on Andy Russell's website (
Circular State of Mind  ) and Andy has reacted:
August 27, 2012
An exchange between
Robberts helper Enrico
and UK researcher,
Andy Russell

Bottom of page.